Save Pin
This Werther’s White Russian is a delightful twist on a classic cocktail, bringing together the rich warmth of coffee and the buttery sweetness reminiscent of your grandma’s favorite candy. Perfect for holiday gatherings or an indulgent evening treat, it balances bold flavors and creamy texture in a way that feels both nostalgic and sophisticated.
I first tried this cocktail during a holiday party, and it instantly became a favorite—my friends loved the mix of sweet and strong, and I enjoyed how effortlessly it felt festive without being overly complicated.
Ingredients
- Store-bought butterscotch syrup: creates a luscious, sweet rim that echoes the candy’s flavor, choose a good-quality syrup for the best result
- Crushed butterscotch candies: adds texture and makes the glass look inviting crush finely for even coating
- Overproof rum (over 80 proof): brings strength and warmth go for a spiced or aged variety to enhance complexity
- Cold coffee: the backbone of the cocktail’s flavor freshly brewed then chilled works best
- Kahlúa: a coffee liqueur that deepens the coffee notes and adds sweetness
- Triple sec: a citrusy liqueur that cuts through the richness with a hint of brightness
- Ice: large cubes preferred to slow melting and prevent dilution
- Whole milk or half-and-half: for creaminess and balance use fresh and full-fat for that velvet mouthfeel
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Dip the Rim:
- Dip syrup into a shallow bowl and spread crushed candies on a plate. Carefully rim your glass with syrup by dipping it in first, then coat evenly with the crushed candies for a sweet and textured edge.
- Mix the Liquids:
- Add rum, cold coffee, Kahlúa, and triple sec to the prepared glass. Stir gently to blend the flavors while being careful not to disturb the candy rim.
- Add Ice and Milk:
- Fill the glass with a large cube or plenty of ice to chill the drink. Slowly pour whole milk or half-and-half over the top, allowing it to swirl and mix naturally with the coffee and spirits.
- Garnish With Candy:
- Place a whole butterscotch candy on the rim as a nostalgic touch that also invites you to nibble as you sip.
Save Pin
My favorite part is the crushed butterscotch rim which not only adds sweetness but also a little fun texture every time you take a sip. It reminds me of cozy winter nights with my grandma sharing stories and treats, which makes this cocktail feel truly special.
Storage Tips
Store any leftover coffee and syrup separately in the fridge for up to two days to keep flavors fresh. The cocktail itself is best enjoyed immediately once mixed, as the candy rim will soften and milk can separate if left too long. You can prepare the rim in advance but wait until serving to assemble the drink fully.
Ingredient Substitutions
If you cannot find butterscotch syrup, a good quality caramel syrup works nicely but will change the flavor slightly toward richer caramel notes. For milk options, half-and-half provides extra creaminess, but whole milk keeps it lighter. Spiced rum can replace overproof rum if you want a bit more aromatic complexity with less alcohol strength.
Serving Suggestions
This cocktail pairs beautifully with rich desserts like pecan pie or chocolate truffles, matching the warmth and sweetness of the drink. It also works well as a cozy pre-dinner sipper during holiday gatherings or late-night chats by the fire.
Cultural Context
The White Russian cocktail is a classic from the mid-20th century known for its smooth, creamy coffee flavor balanced with vodka or rum. This version reimagines the original with the nostalgic flavor of butterscotch, linking old-fashioned candies to modern mixology trends where comfort food meets cocktail craft.
Commonly Asked Questions
- → What gives this drink its creamy texture?
The creamy texture comes from the addition of whole milk or half-and-half, which blends smoothly with the coffee and spirits.
- → Can I substitute the overproof rum?
Yes, you can use a dark rum with a lower proof, but it may alter the boldness and strength of the drink.
- → How should I prepare the glass rim?
Dip the glass rim into butterscotch syrup, then coat it with crushed butterscotch candies for a sweet, decorative touch.
- → Is fresh coffee or cold brew better for this drink?
Cold coffee works best to maintain the drink's smoothness and avoid dilution, preserving the bold flavors.
- → What is the purpose of the triple sec?
Triple sec adds a subtle citrus brightness that balances the richness of the butterscotch and coffee.