Save Pin
This homemade Wendy’s Frosty recipe lets you enjoy the creamy classic chocolate treat right from your kitchen with just four simple ingredients and a blender. It hits that perfect balance of vanilla and chocolate that makes the original so addictive and can be whipped up whenever the craving strikes.
When my husband gets a Frosty craving this is the recipe he requests every single time. One summer it became our weekly Friday night tradition especially when our girls joined in for a Frosty and fries.
Ingredients
- Chocolate milk powder: This gives you the signature chocolate flavor and makes all the difference between regular chocolate syrup and the Wendy’s taste. You can use any brand but Nesquik is my go to for getting that closest match to the original
- Vanilla ice cream: This makes sure your Frosty is light enough just like the restaurant version. Choose full fat ice cream for the creamiest consistency and check that it is real vanilla rather than imitation for best flavor
- Whole milk: Using whole milk gets you closest to the super creamy thick texture but you can substitute lower fat if needed. Always choose fresh cold milk
- Powdered sugar: This sweetens the mix without making it gritty. Sift your powdered sugar to avoid any lumps for the smoothest drink
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Add the ingredients:
- Start by scooping your vanilla ice cream into the blender followed by the chocolate milk powder and sifted powdered sugar. Pour in the whole milk last to help it blend smoothly
- Blend until thick and creamy:
- Turn the blender to medium first then high. Use a tamper or spatula to make sure everything blends evenly. Keep blending for about one minute until the mixture is totally smooth and just thick enough to spoon up
- Check and adjust:
- Pause to taste and make sure the flavor is perfect. If you want a thinner Frosty add a splash more milk and pulse. If you like it thicker add a little extra ice cream and blend
- Serve immediately:
- Pour the Frosty into chilled glasses. If you want the true Wendy’s experience let it sit two to three minutes so the edges soften slightly just like at the drive thru
- Toppings optional:
- If you are feeling fancy top with whipped cream and some sprinkles or a cherry for a festive touch
Save Pin
I always look forward to adding that extra scoop of chocolate milk powder when my husband is in charge. It reminds me of how he used to carefully ration his Frosty keychain freebies and always shared with our two daughters huddled around the kitchen counter.
Storage Tips
This homemade Frosty is at its best fresh from the blender. If you do have leftovers they can be stored in the freezer for up to a couple hours. Be prepared for a firmer texture after freezing and give it a quick stir before serving again. I do not recommend storing overnight as the texture will get icy.
Ingredient Substitutions
If you do not have chocolate milk powder you can use sweetened cocoa powder but you will get a slightly more pronounced chocolate taste. For a non dairy version swap in your favorite plant based vanilla ice cream and whole fat oat or almond milk. Lactose free ice cream and milk also work well if needed.
Serving Suggestions
Serve your Frosty straight up in tall glasses with a straw or a spoon. If you love the classic combo try dipping fresh hot fries in your Frosty for that sweet and salty Wendy’s inspired treat. For a party make a Frosty float with cola or root beer and a maraschino cherry on top.
Save Pin
A Little History
The original Wendy’s Frosty released in 1969 was specifically crafted with a mild chocolate flavor that would not overpower the taste of hamburgers and fries. Dave Thomas the founder was very intentional about mixing chocolate and vanilla to create that signature light taste. Making it at home has become a bit of a family tradition for us especially when we want to bring a little drive thru nostalgia to movie night.
Commonly Asked Questions
- → What ingredients give the Frosty its signature flavor?
Vanilla ice cream and chocolate milk powder combine to create the classic frosty taste, while powdered sugar adds sweetness and milk ensures the right creamy consistency.
- → Why use vanilla ice cream instead of chocolate?
Vanilla ice cream blended with chocolate milk powder closely mimics the original, balanced chocolate flavor of the classic fast-food frosty treat.
- → Can I use a milk alternative?
Yes, though whole milk gives the creamiest texture, you can use skim, non-dairy, or nonfat milk—just note the texture may vary slightly.
- → How do I get the authentic frosty texture?
Use a powerful blender to blend all ingredients until smooth and thick. Serve immediately for best results, or briefly freeze for an even thicker consistency.
- → Are there fun toppings to try?
Absolutely! Whipped cream, sprinkles, chocolate shavings, or even a cherry on top add extra fun and flavor to your frosty.
- → Can I prepare this ahead of time?
For optimal texture, serve promptly after blending. However, you can freeze leftovers and soften slightly before serving again.