Save Pin
This Turkeytini cocktail is the perfect blend of dessert and drink to end your Thanksgiving feast on a high note. Rich with the flavors of Baileys Irish cream, chocolate liqueur, Kahlúa, and bourbon, it delivers a creamy, boozy treat that feels like a celebration in every sip. The touch of chocolate syrup and nutmeg on top adds a festive flair, while the optional Reese's turkey garnish brings a playful holiday spirit to your glass.
I first made this recipe for a Thanksgiving gathering, and it was the hit of the night. Everyone loved the creamy mocha flavors paired with bourbon warmth.
Ingredients
- Chocolate syrup: for drizzling adds sweetness and visual appeal, use a thick syrup for best effect
- Baileys Irish cream: introduces a creamy richness that makes the cocktail decadent
- Bourbon: brings a warming depth and balances the sweetness of the liqueurs
- Chocolate liqueur: intensifies the chocolate notes making it almost dessert-like
- Kahlúa: adds a coffee flavor that complements both chocolate and bourbon
- Milk: lightens the cocktail for a smooth finish without overpowering the other flavors, use whole milk for the best texture
- Ice: to chill and shake the cocktail properly
- Grated fresh nutmeg: for garnish a fragrant touch that complements the creamy spices
- Oreo turkey garnish: optional but adorable, great for holiday fun and presentation
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Drizzle the Chocolate:
- Drizzle chocolate syrup inside your martini or coupe glass in a swirling pattern. This adds both a beautiful look and extra chocolate flavor. Place the glass in the freezer while you prepare the cocktail so the syrup sets without running.
- Mix the Liquids:
- In a cocktail shaker combine Baileys Irish cream, bourbon, chocolate liqueur, Kahlúa, and milk. Each of these adds a layer of flavor making the drink rich, complex, and smooth.
- Shake it Up:
- Add plenty of ice to the shaker, cover it, and shake vigorously for about 20 seconds until the outside of the shaker becomes very frosty. This chilling and mixing gives you the smooth frothy texture that prevents separation or curdling.
- Strain and Garnish:
- Strain the cocktail carefully into your prepared chilled glass so none of the ice goes in. Grate fresh nutmeg over the top for an aromatic finishing touch. If you want to add a bit of whimsy, create the Reese’s turkey garnish using 2 candy eyes, a Reese’s Thins cup, candy corn, and melted chocolate as glue. Place it on the glass rim or floating gently on the surface.
Save Pin
My favorite ingredient is Baileys because it adds that creamy luxurious feel that transforms this from a simple mixed drink to a decadent dessert in a glass. One year I brought these to a friendsgiving party and everyone wanted the recipe immediately.
Storage Tips
This cocktail is best served fresh and chilled so it should be made right before serving. However if you want to prepare a batch in advance keep the mixed ingredients (except milk) refrigerated in a sealed container. Add the milk and shake well just before serving to maintain that perfect frothy texture.
Ingredient Substitutions
For a non-dairy option swap the milk with almond or oat milk but expect a slightly different texture. If you do not have chocolate liqueur try crème de cacao or even a splash of chocolate syrup but reduce the syrup on the glass. You can swap bourbon for rye whiskey or spiced rum depending on your flavor preference giving a different but delicious twist.
Serving Suggestions
Serve the Turkeytini in a chilled cocktail glass with a drizzle of chocolate syrup inside for a festive presentation. Pair with bite-sized desserts like mini brownies or chocolate truffles to enhance the mocha notes. Add the Reese’s turkey garnish for a seasonal touch that sparks smiles and conversation.
Cultural and Historical Context
Dessert cocktails like this have grown in popularity as they combine two favorites in one glass making celebrations feel extra indulgent. This recipe nods to Thanksgiving by cleverly incorporating the turkey theme through its garnish and rich autumnal flavors of nutmeg and bourbon.
Pro Tips
Always shake your cocktail long enough to get it frosty and well mixed which prevents separation. Freeze your glass with the chocolate syrup drizzle so it stays in place and looks beautiful when you pour in the drink. Be gentle straining the cocktail to keep the froth intact that makes each sip so smooth and creamy.
Commonly Asked Questions
- → What makes the Turkeytini smooth and frothy?
Shaking the mixture vigorously for at least 20 seconds chills and emulsifies the ingredients, creating a smooth, frothy texture without separation.
- → Can I prepare multiple servings at once?
Yes, simply multiply the ingredient amounts and shake in batches to maintain the proper frothy consistency for each glass.
- → What is the purpose of the chocolate syrup swirl inside the glass?
The chocolate syrup adds a visually appealing design and a hint of extra chocolate flavor enhancing each sip as you drink.
- → Is the Oreo turkey garnish necessary for the flavor?
No, it’s optional and mainly adds a fun, festive touch, though it complements the drink’s flavors nicely.
- → What ingredient provides the subtle spice on top?
Freshly grated nutmeg is sprinkled on top, adding a warm, aromatic spice that brightens the creamy drink.