Save Pin
Frankenstein’s Monster Brownies turn an ordinary baking day into a hands-on decorating adventure with kids or friends. Melted chocolate, cocoa richness, and playful toppings give these brownies a bold personality and make them the star of any Halloween party or fun gathering.
You can prep these ahead and get creative with decorations. The first time I made them, everyone ended up with icing on their fingers but nobody cared because we were all busy laughing and trying to make the spookiest monster faces.
Ingredients
- Brownie mix: choose your favorite brand for the base and check that it is fudgy for the best texture
- Green food coloring: brings the Frankenstein monster to life and makes the treats pop at any party
- Chocolate frosting: for rich flavor and as the foundation for decorations opt for bakery thick frosting
- Black decorating gel: makes bold faces and gives character to every ‘monster’
- Candy eyes: look for large or assorted sizes for more expression
- Mini pretzel sticks: add a delicious crunch and act as ‘monster neck bolts’
- M and M’s or candy-coated chocolates: for extra color and creative embellishments choose colors that match your monster’s mood
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Batter
- Follow the directions on your boxed brownie mix. Mix until just combined for the fudgiest results. If you want extra chocolate bits or texture stir in a handful of chocolate chunks or crushed pretzels now.
- Bake the Brownies
- Pour the batter into a lined pan. Gently tap the pan to even out the surface. Bake as directed. Let brownies cool completely in the pan for easier cutting.
- Chill and Cut
- Cover the cooled pan and pop it into the fridge for 20 minutes. Cold brownies are much easier to slice cleanly. Cut into rectangles or squares to create monster ‘heads’.
- Color and Frost
- Spoon some chocolate frosting into a bowl. Swirl in green food coloring until you get a bold monster green. Spread a thick and even layer onto each brownie top using a small offset spatula for smoothness.
- Decorate Faces
- Drop a small dab of frosting to stick on one or two candy eyes. Use black decorating gel to add zigzag hair lines a monster’s mouth or even scars. This is where the personality shines.
- Add the Final Touches
- Press mini pretzel sticks gently into the sides for the monster’s neck bolts. Stick on M and M’s or favorite candies for added fun. Repeat with the rest of the brownies. Each monster will look unique.
Save Pin
I always love how candy eyes can turn even a lumpy brownie into something hilarious. My favorite memory is watching my niece try to give her monster “eyebrows” with crushed pretzels only to make him look more confused than scary. These brownies truly bring out everyone’s creative side.
Storage Tips
Keep decorated brownies in a single layer in an airtight container. Separate layers with wax paper to keep the faces intact. Most decorations stay firm for up to two days at room temperature or four days refrigerated.
Ingredient Substitutions
Out of green food coloring Use a tiny bit of yellow and blue mixed together. No chocolate frosting Try vanilla with a touch of green for a brighter Frankenstein. Replace pretzel sticks with cereal straws or chopped nuts for neck bolts and added texture.
Save Pin
Serving Suggestions
Arrange brownies on a platter with gummy worms or candy pumpkins for full spooky effect. Serve with hot chocolate or a simple scoop of vanilla ice cream to balance their richness. If making for a bake sale individually wrap them for easy grab and go treats.
Cultural Context
The Frankenstein monster theme comes from classic horror stories and lends itself perfectly to Halloween traditions. Decorating monster treats is a treasured ritual in many families bringing people together no matter their age or baking skill.
Commonly Asked Questions
- → How do you achieve the green monster color?
Swirl green food coloring into the chocolate frosting before spreading on the cooled brownies to create that classic monster green look.
- → Can I add textural elements besides pretzels?
Absolutely! Try crushed nuts, cereal, or candy-coated chocolates for added crunch and flavor alongside or instead of pretzels.
- → What kind of brownie base works best?
A classic box mix or your favorite homemade base will work—aim for a fudgy rather than cakey texture for the richest monster heads.
- → How do I decorate monster faces?
Use black decorating gel for hair, mouths, and scars, then apply candy eyes for a whimsical touch. Add colorful candies for extra flair.
- → How should these brownies be served?
Let brownies cool and firm before slicing, then decorate and serve at room temperature for best flavor and texture.