Save Pin
Nothing hits the spot quite like a juicy steak kissed by a rich bourbon garlic cream sauce. This restaurant-style dinner is pure comfort with a little mysterious twist. The haunted sauce takes everyday steak up a notch and makes weeknight meals feel like a special occasion in our house.
I stumbled on this sauce one October inspired by leftover bourbon and a craving for something extra. My family now asks for haunted steak at every chilly-weather gathering.
- Boneless New York strip steak: choose a 12-ounce cut for flavor and tenderness
- Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper: brings out the natural umami and gives a proper crust
- Neutral cooking oil: pick an oil with a high smoke point like canola or grapeseed
- Cold unsalted butter: adds creaminess and helps brown the steak deeply
- Garlic: both smashed and finely chopped for layered flavor
- Bourbon: use a good quality for smooth richness
- Low-sodium chicken broth: allows the sauce to shine without being too salty
- Heavy cream: creates a velvety finish
- Fresh herbs like thyme or rosemary: use fresh sprigs for fragrance
- Red wine: choose a bold dry varietal if using for extra depth
- Caramelized shallots: optional but bring sweetness
- Smoked paprika: offers gentle warmth and color
- Choose a marbled steak and the freshest garlic possible: for the best flavor foundation
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Steak:
- Pat the steak until dry using paper towels then season evenly with kosher salt and black pepper on all sides. Let it sit uncovered at room temperature for thirty minutes to ensure even cooking and a perfect crust.
- Sear the Steak:
- Heat a cast-iron skillet until almost smoking. Add neutral oil then lay the steak in away from you. Sear each side for three to four minutes without disturbing for a deep golden crust.
- Butter Baste:
- Lower the heat and add cold butter and two smashed cloves of garlic. Use a spoon to continuously baste the steak with melted butter and toasty garlic for one minute. Flip and baste the other side.
- Rest the Steak:
- Transfer the steak to a plate and cover loosely with foil. Let it rest for eight minutes to keep juices locked in.
- Make the Haunted Bourbon Garlic Cream Sauce:
- In the same pan pour off excess fat and add chopped garlic. Cook on medium-low for two minutes scraping up the brown bits. Carefully add bourbon and ignite if you want a subtle flame for drama. Let the alcohol cook off then pour in chicken broth and simmer for two minutes. Stir in heavy cream and any fresh herbs or extras. Cook until the sauce has thickened to your liking.
- Finish and Serve:
- Slice steak against the grain and pour sauce generously over each slice. Sprinkle with fresh herbs and a hint of smoked paprika if you like.
Save Pin
For me the joy is always in the first taste of the sauce. The smell of garlic sizzling in bourbon fills the kitchen and somehow gathers everyone around the stove. Every fall this is the dish that makes my family linger a while longer together.
Storage Tips
Leftover steak keeps well in the fridge for up to three days. Slice before storing and keep the sauce in a separate airtight container. Warm gently to avoid overcooking the meat and to keep the sauce creamy not greasy.
Ingredient Substitutions
Swap strip steak for ribeye or filet mignon if you prefer. Use brandy instead of bourbon or omit alcohol and add a splash of apple cider for depth. For non-dairy try coconut cream for a different creamy note.
Save Pin
Serving Suggestions
Serve with mashed potatoes or crusty bread to soak up the extra sauce. Roasted Brussels sprouts or steamed green beans make this meal hearty and balanced. If you want something lighter a crisp salad works beautifully.
Cultural Note
Bourbon sauces trace their roots to American steakhouse kitchens. Their drama and aroma make the meal feel worthy of celebration. My haunted garlic twist is perfect for fall and Halloween gatherings but it is right at home any time you crave comfort.
When I serve this at home guests go silent for just a minute as the flavors hit then conversations start and no one can believe it started with pantry basics.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I achieve a perfect steak sear
Pat the steak dry season well and use a hot cast-iron skillet with oil. Sear each side for caramelization.
What does bourbon add to the sauce
Bourbon lends a deep smoky sweetness that balances the creamy garlic sauce enhancing the steak's flavor.
Can I substitute another cut for New York strip
Yes ribeye or sirloin both work well. Adjust cook time based on thickness and desired doneness.
Should I rest the steak after cooking
Absolutely. Resting helps the juices redistribute resulting in tender juicy slices.
What herbs pair best with this steak
Fresh thyme and rosemary complement the savory and creamy aspects of the bourbon garlic sauce.
Commonly Asked Questions
- → How do I achieve a perfect steak sear?
Pat the steak dry, season generously, and use a very hot cast-iron skillet with a neutral oil. Sear undisturbed for deep caramelization, then finish with butter and garlic basting.
- → What flavor does bourbon bring to the sauce?
Bourbon adds notes of smokiness and caramel, balancing the richness of garlic and cream for a harmonious finishing sauce.
- → Which steak cuts work besides New York strip?
Ribeye or filet mignon are excellent alternatives. Adjust cook time to the thickness and preferred doneness of your chosen cut.
- → Why is resting important after cooking steak?
Resting allows juices to redistribute through the steak, ensuring moist, tender slices instead of dryness when serving.
- → Which herbs complement bourbon garlic steak?
Fresh thyme and rosemary deliver fragrance and subtle flavor that highlight the cream sauce and savory steak base.
- → How should leftovers be stored for best results?
Slice steak and keep sauce separate, storing both in airtight containers in the fridge for up to three days. Reheat gently to maintain texture.