
Soft Christmas peppermints are the ultimate nostalgic treat that fill your home with festive energy and a sweet peppermint scent. These little confections are as magical to make as they are to eat and remind me of the afternoons spent with my grandma shaping each candy by hand. Their meltaway texture and gentle coolness are comfort in candy form and they are always the first thing to disappear from the holiday sweets table.
Making these brings back wonderful memories of laughter and sticky fingers from rolling candies with loved ones. Every batch wraps a bit of that holiday joy and togetherness into a bite-sized treat.
Ingredients
- Granulated sugar: brings necessary sweetness and structure Choose cane sugar for purity
- Corn syrup: adds smoothness and prevents crystallization Use clear corn syrup for the best texture
- Water: provides the essential liquid base Use filtered water if possible
- Peppermint extract: supplies that signature cool flavor Seek a pure extract for the freshest taste
- Red food coloring: creates the classic festive swirl Gel colors give vibrant results without thinning the mixture
- Powdered sugar: is used for dusting to prevent candy from sticking Always choose a fresh finely milled confectioners sugar for best coating
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Cooking the Candy Mixture:
- Combine sugar corn syrup and water in a medium saucepan Place over medium heat and stir gently until the sugar fully dissolves Continue heating and watching closely Allow the mixture to reach two hundred sixty degrees Fahrenheit using a candy thermometer This ensures the right soft but set consistency Remove from heat immediately once the temperature is reached to avoid overcooking
- Adding Flavor and Color:
- Carefully stir in the peppermint extract The mixture will smell wonderfully fresh Divide into two heatproof bowls For a festive look add red food coloring to one bowl and stir until thoroughly blended A few drops will give a bold color but adjust as needed for your preferred shade
- Shaping the Candies:
- Let the mixtures cool for about ten minutes until they are safe to touch but still pliable Knead each portion until smooth and workable Dust lightly with powdered sugar to manage stickiness Form the white candy into small balls and flatten slightly Roll the red candy into ropes then twist around the white pieces Press gently to shape a traditional peppermint Each gets a final dusting of powdered sugar Place on parchment and let stand until set usually two hours

The pure peppermint extract is my favorite because it delivers that crisp clean flavor that makes these candies taste like winter cheer itself. Some of my happiest childhood holiday memories are tied to the smell of peppermint wafting from the kitchen while I worked side by side with my grandma rolling the sweet dough into perfect stripes.
Storage Tips
Keep your soft Christmas peppermints in a tightly sealed airtight container to maintain their texture
Layer with sheets of parchment or a sprinkle of powdered sugar if stacking to prevent them from sticking together
Room temperature storage is best but refrigeration extends freshness if your kitchen is warm
Ingredient Substitutions
You can swap out peppermint for spearmint or add a touch of vanilla extract for a smooth note
If you do not use red coloring consider making them all white or using natural beet powder for color
Corn syrup alternatives like golden syrup may slightly change texture but will work in a pinch
Serving Suggestions
Pile them high on a festive plate as a classic table centerpiece
Tuck them into clear bags tied with ribbon for charming homemade gifts
Crumble over hot cocoa or bake into cookies for a sweet seasonal twist

Cultural and Historical Context
Peppermint candies have long been a part of Christmas traditions in Europe and America Symbolizing winter and freshness they were once handmade exclusively for holiday markets Today soft peppermints revive that nostalgic handmade touch in an era of mass produced sweets Bringing them back is like reviving a piece of edible history
Commonly Asked Questions
- → Can I use flavors other than peppermint?
Yes, you can substitute with extracts like vanilla or almond to create different flavors and personalize these candies.
- → How should I store these sweets?
Store in an airtight container at room temperature. Separate layers with powdered sugar for up to two weeks of freshness.
- → What if the candy mixture is too sticky?
Dust your hands and work surface with powdered sugar while shaping to reduce stickiness for easier handling.
- → Is it possible to customize the color?
Absolutely! Use different food colorings to match your seasonal décor or add a creative twist to your candies.
- → Can these candies be made ahead?
They can be prepared in advance and stored for gifting or holiday parties without losing their softness or flavor.
- → Are these suitable for freezing?
For longer storage, wrap candies individually and freeze. Allow to thaw before serving for best texture.